This is an interesting example of how point of view can change a story completely. Get an answer for in the odyssey, what survival qualities does odysseus exhibit in his conflict with polyphemus. When morning comes, odysseus and his men escape from the cave, unseen by the blind polyphemus, by clinging to the. Ulysses and the cyclops polyphemus odyssey, book ix. Odysseus does not discuss, at this point, why he was blown off course and unable to return directly.
That odysseus is willing to stab polyphemus, but remembers that doing so would prevent his and his crews ability to escape the cave shows. For all of his stupidity and brutishness, polyphemus strikes some commentators as vaguely sympathetic at the end of book 9. In the odyssey, what survival qualities does odysseus. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. According to these wise guys, everything after odysseus and penelope go to bed togetherincluding all of book xxivwas added later by somebody other than homer. Get an answer for in book 9 of the odyssey, why does poseidon curse odysseus for blinding his son, polyphemus. He then takes twelve men and sets out to find supplies.
Study 38 terms the odyssey book 9 flashcards quizlet. No one has time to read them all, but its important to go over them at least briefly. Summary and analysis book 9 in the oneeyed giants cave. I called out, and polyphemus came to the edge of the seaside cliff. A stage version 1993 at the close of the ninth book of the odyssey odysseus and the other survivors from polyphemus cave rejoin the rest of. In the odyssey book 9 where did the cyclops live answers. He didnt see us at first, but went about his business. Narrative and thematic techniques in books 9 and 19 of the. Rewrite an adventure from the odyssey from the point of view. At dawn polyphemus lit the fire, milked his sheep, and ate two more men for breakfast. The odyssey is fundamental to the modern western canon. He let the ram go, and we beat it down to the ship as fast as our legs would carry us. Homer, odyssey book 9 theoi classical texts library.
I wish you could talk, so you could point out those greeks. Who is the narrator of the book odysseus book 9 answers. In book 9 of homers the odyssey, we learn more about his travels after the trojan war ended and why he still has not made. They took the stake of olivewood, sharp at the point, and thrust it into his eye, while i, throwing my weight upon it from above, whirled it round, as when a man bores a ships timber 385 with a drill, while those below keep it spinning with the thong, which they lay hold of. The point of view shifts entirely to odysseus during books 912, when he tells about his adventures at sea before landing on calypsos island, making the poem feel like a firstperson account for a lengthy stretch of narrative. Have your students practice writing by recasting a scene from the odyssey from other characters perspectives. Dec 04, 2011 50 thoughts on week of 124 the odyssey book 9 nick k 4 december 5, 2011 at 3. In fact, two scholars from ancient alexandria claimed that the ending of the odyssey came in line 296of book xxiii. Odysseus does not discuss, at this point, why he was blown off course and unable to return directly to ithaca. In homers odyssey book 9, odysseus lands on the island of the cyclopes during his journey home from the trojan war.
Nobody, friendspolyphemus bellowed back from his cave. Homer even gives us a metaphor for the poems tone, when he compares odysseus stringing his bow to a singer tuning his lyre book xxi, lines 404411. Retell the adventues from this creatures point of view. Book 9 book 10 book 11 book 12 book book 14 book 15 book 16 book 17 book 18 book 19 book 20. It is also interesting, that nowhere homer mentions this very particular feature of polyphemus i. The weary warriors come in peace, but polyphemus idea of a warm welcome for the men is to grab a couple of them, bash their skulls on the ground, and eat them as a. Odysseus finally reveals his identity to alkinoos and the phaiakians. Compare and contrast goliath and polyphemus and david and odysseus. But his pride in his name foreshadows odysseus questionable judgment in identifying himself during the escape from polyphemus. Polyphemus whose prayer for revenge was the origin of. He took polyphemus club and his men filed it down to a point and singed it at the end. Terms in this set 15 odysseus narrates his adventures using what point of view is book 9 of the odyssey. In the odyssey, what survival qualities does odysseus exhibit. Odysseus tells the cyclops that his name is nobody, such that when he blinds the cyclops and the cyclops asks for help from his countrymen, the cyclops can only exclaim that nobody is attacking him, leading his countrymen to.
I got up to see the sun rise, and then i went into the forest to find something to eat for breakfast. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemuss point of view essay. Polyphemus, the cyclops of homers the odyssey, isnt a nice guy. Odysseus insisted on entering the cave to befriend the cyclope polyphemus, therefor he was the one who initially put them in danger. At dusk polyphemus returned, milked his sheep and goats. He then left for the day, shutting the entrance of the cave behind him with the huge rock. Rewriting scenes from the odyssey from another point of. The greeks find and enter a large cave, the home of the great cyclops polyphemus. We cut off a sixfoot section, skinned it, put a sharp point on one end and. Essay on book 9 of the odyssey book 9 12 odyssey essay. The mountain like appearance of polyphemus according to homer odyssey book 9, 190 makes that sound plausible. I use it in my 9th grade classes and it works so well. The odyssey books 912 summary and analysis gradesaver. Books 9 through 12 are told as flashbacks, as odysseus sits in the palace of the phaeacians telling the story of his wanderings.
We learn that poseidon, god of the sea, holds a grudge though we dont know exactly why against odysseus and is making the guys voyage home a pretty difficult one. When the cyclops polyphemus was his name came home that afternoon. The odyssey from circes point of view prospect magazine. I leaned on it turning it as a shipwright turns a drill in. Up to this point in the book, odysseus had not revealed his actual name to king alcinoos. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemus s point of view the average student has to read dozens of books per year. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemus s point of view 796 words 2 pages joel schain period 2 32810 book 9. I am odysseus, son of laertes, who 20 am known among men for all manner. The next four books books 912 deal with the heros wanderings and are the most widely known in the epic. In these sections the narrator interrupts odysseus a few times to remind the audience where they are. In his fury he tore up a huge boulder and flung it at us. She felt hatred towards everyone and everything, and fell into a deep state of dark, sadness. One epic simile in the fitzgerald translation of the odyssey is when odysseus describes the scene of the cyclops polyphemus. Oct 18, 2012 the odyssey book 9 summary at the end of the last book, odysseus was asked to tell his story about where he came from.
As the giant became drunk, odysseus mentioned that his own name was nobody. Lord alcinous, renowned above all men, verily this is a good thing, to listen to a minstrel such as this man is, like unto the gods in voice. When the cyclops polyphemus was his name came home that afternoon, he blotted out the light in. Students write from the point of view of the cyclops. Great supplemental information for school essays and projects. Starts with essay question about whether polyphemus was a monster or lonely creature, transitions to 10 minute teacher lecture re. The next four books books 9 12 deal with the heros wanderings and are the most widely known in the epic. Thrice i brought and gave it him, and thrice he drained it in his folly. But the polyphemus episode is important beyond serving as a plot point.
This is to help study the importaint events and characters in book 9. The epic is retold, along with many other classical texts, by the witch circe as narrator, a figure whose transformation of men into swine has been used to allegorise humanitys. How would you explain the the cyclops from polyphemus. The cyclops part of homers odyssey retold in flashback from polyphemus the cyclopss pov. Include thoughts and feelings the creature would have. The poet invokes the muse to help him tell the story of odysseus. Rewriting scenes from the odyssey from another point of view. I enjoyed reading the odyssey books 9 12 and look forward to part two.
Odysseus and the cyclops greek, from the odyssey, by homer. Jan 26, 2009 in homers odyssey book 9, odysseus lands on the island of the cyclopes during his journey home from the trojan war. Brown odysseus god gave us two eyes because were human. For instance, when it is raining outside, my first thought would probably.
Polyphemus whose prayer for revenge was the origin of the. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemuss point of view bartleby. In book 9 of the odyssey, why does poseidon curse odysseus. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemus s point of view words study guides and book summaries from parent seminars, to books excuse movies, to even games consoles, children are not only being taught the basic concepts of the world, shapes, colors, language, but they are also electricity taught the norms and values of a particular society. May 12, 2017 the story of odysseus and the cyclops polyphemus. Polyphemus wakes with a shriek, and his neighbors come to see what is wrong, but they leave as soon as he calls out, nobodys killing me 9. These books thus give background not only to odysseus s audience but to homers as well.
I got up to see the sun rise, and then i went into the forest to. In order to cope, she wrote in a book for every day telemachus was gone. How would you explain the the cyclops from polyphemus point. The odyssey book 9 the cyclops lyrics in this passage, odysseus and his men have just escaped the land of the lotuseaters, where they given fruit causing the crew to forget about going home. An example of this is because in book 9 of homers odyssey, odysseusoutwits the cyclops and wrenches out his eye, and then is able to escape with all his men whilst holding on to two of his sheep. What is an epic simile from book 9 of the odyssey answers. Zeus comments that poseidon will need to stop pouting at some point and get over himself already, since all the other gods like odysseus so much. Odysseus is most responsible for the deaths in book 9 of the odyssey. When polyphemus returns, odysseus gets him drunk on wine that he brought along from the ship. Murray 1 then odysseus, of many wiles, answered him, and said. Then from out the cave the mighty polyphemus answered them. Odysseus offered polyphemus his strong wine, and polyphemus drank three bowls. Rewrite an adventure from the odyssey from the point of view of another character. In the eyes of polyphemus this morning was like any other day.
The videos are short, to the point, and the quiz allows me to test their knowledge on whatever subject. But when the wine had stolen about the wits of the cyclops, then i spoke to him with gentle words. After 10 years of fighting against troy, odysseus, one of the victorious greek. Summary and analysis book 1 athena inspires the prince summary homer opens the odyssey with an invocation to the muse of epic poetry and asks for her guidance in telling the story of a man who has experienced many twists and turns of fate and has suffered many hardships. Well even send you our prospects top thinkers ebook free when you do. What is the goal of odysseuss quest in the odyssey. The first of these, book 9, involves odysseus encounter with polyphemus, the maneating cyclops. Odysseus introduces himself and begins his story, starting with the moment his men leave troy. When we were a good way out to sea, i could not resist a taunt. Therefore has zeus taken vengeance on thee, and the other gods. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. The importance of point of view robert and the dog point of view in a story is something i find extremely interesting, simply because of the obvious fact that every single one of us have our own way of seeing things. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemus s point of view. The basic geographic orientation of the odyssey begins with troy, which was on the coast of the country known today as turkey.
Have students read the story of david and goliath after reading the odyssey, book 9, where odysseus escapes the cyclops, in order to make connections between character and theme. Odysseus does not discuss, at this point, why he was blown off course and. A discussion of the the odyssey themes running throughout the odyssey. The most famous paradox in the odyssey is the trick by which odysseus outwits and escapes the cyclops in book 9. The cyclopes are lawless and do not believe in the gods that the greeks believe in despite polyphemus being poisidens son o. Scholars believe the odyssey was composed near the end of the 8th century bc, somewhere in ionia, the greek coastal region of anatolia. As we saw in book viii, in which odysseus angrily reacted to an athletic challenge, he is prone to rash decisions. Students familiar with some of the legends of the odyssey but new to the epic itself might be surprised to see that the section on the lotuseaters is only about twentyfive lines long 9. The allusion to the greek king agamemnon who led war against the trojans makes what point of odysseus. At dusk polyphemus returned, milked his sheep and goats, and ate two more men for dinner. Book 9 of the odyssey from polyphemuss point of view. Insight book 9 of the odyssey in the cyclops perspective.
599 716 1180 508 582 116 1164 413 1428 377 1230 49 280 1255 1107 685 1626 710 463 524 1202 219 188 431 116 345 1106 1090 493 263 8 1043 251